Tools for Change: An Educator's Resource Site
Helping Students Manage Violence: A Resource Guide for Educators
Author(s): Santina
Camarada, Bronda Cranney, Michelle Moran
Publisher: Kohai
Plus
Type of Resource: classroom
activities
Target Grades: 6-8
Canadian Resource? Yes
Resource formally evaluated? (unknown)
What is the source, internet link, or article title for viewing the formal
evaluation of this resource? (none supplied)
Ministry of Education Expectations
Subject Areas:language,
the arts, health and physical education, social studies, religion,
family life
Expectations Met:
GRADE SIX
Language: Writing
-
Use writing for various purposes and in a range of contexts, including school work (e.g., to develop and clarify ideas, to express thoughts and opinions)
Language: Reading
-
Make judgments and draw conclusions about ideas in written materials on the basis of evidence
Language: Oral and Visual Communication
- Make reports, describe and explain a course of action, and follow
detailed instructions
- Ask and answer questions to obtain and clarify information
- Express and respond to a range of ideas and opinions concisely,
clearly, and appropriately
- Contribute and work constructively in groups
- Use tone of voice and gestures to enhance the message and help
convince or persuade listeners in conversations, discussions, or
presentations
- Use constructive strategies in small-group discussions (e.g.,
invite other group members to contribute; ask questions to clarify
a point; negotiate to find a basis for agreement)
- Follow up on others’ ideas, and recognize the validity
of different points of view in group discussions or problem-solving
activities
The Arts: Drama and Dance
- Evaluate, orally and in writing, their own and others’ work
in drama and dance e.g., performances, multimedia presentations)
- Solve problems presented through drama and dance in different
ways, and evaluate the effectiveness of each solution
- Evaluate drama and dance performances, with reference to their
own experiences in daily life
- Solve artistic problems in drama and dance, individually and
in groups, and evaluate the solutions
- Provide evidence for their interpretations of personal experiences
and events of social significance, which they present through drama
and dance, using a variety of research sources
Health and Physical Education: Healthy Living
- Apply a problem-solving/decision-making process to address issues
related to friends, peers, and family relationships
- Describe and respond appropriately to potentially violent situations
relevant to themselves (e.g., threats, harassment, violence in
the media)
Health and Physical Education: Active Participation
-
Follow the rules of fair play in games and activities, and support the efforts of peers to improve their skills
Catholic Education Religion and Family Life
Family Life:
- valuing human life through the five stages
- effective behaviours and emotions in relationships
- code of behaviour, positive and negative influences in relationships
GRADE SEVEN
Language: Reading
- Make judgments and draw conclusions about ideas in written materials
on the basis of evidence
- Clarify and develop their own points of view by examining the
ideas of others
Language: Oral and Visual Communication
- Ask questions and discuss different aspects of ideas in order
to clarify their thinking
- Express and respond to a range of ideas and opinions concisely,
clearly, and appropriately
- Contribute and work constructively in groups
- Identify some of the ways in which non-verbal communication
techniques (e.g., tone of voice and body language) can affect audiences,
and use these techniques in their own speech to arouse and maintain
interest, and convince and persuade their listeners
- Listen and respond constructively to alternative ideas or viewpoints
- Express ideas and opinions confidently but without trying to
dominate discussion
The Arts: Drama and Dance
- Evaluate, orally and in writing, their own and others’ work
in drama and dance, using criteria developed by the class
- Solve, in various ways, a problem that is presented through
drama and dance, and explain ways in which each solution is effective
Health and Physical Education: Healthy Living
- Explain how harassment relates to personal safety
- Use effective communication skills (e.g., refusal skills, active
listening) to deal with various relationships and situations
- Describe harassment and identify ways of dealing with it (e.g.,
by communicating feelings and reporting incidents of harassment)
- Identify people and resources that can support someone experiencing
harassment
Health and Physical Education: Active Participation
-
Participate fairly in games or activities (e.g., accepting and respecting decisions made by officials, whether they are students, teachers, or coaches)
History: Conflict and Change
- Demonstrate an understanding of the nature of change and conflict,
methods of creating change, and methods of resolving conflicts
- Examine and communicate methods of conflict resolution employed
in everyday life: at home, at school, in the community
- Compare strategies of conflict resolution used at home and at
school to strategies used historically
Catholic Education Religion and Family Life
Religion:
Family Life:
- self respect equals the respect of others
- changing relationships in adolescence
- changing human relationships
- freedom and responsible decision making
- exploring the social nature of humans in community
GRADE EIGHT
Language: Reading
- Explain their interpretations of a written work, supporting
it with evidence from the work and from their own knowledge and
experience
- Make judgments and draw conclusions about ideas in written materials
on the basis of evidence
- Clarify and broaden their own points of view by examining the
ideas of others
Language: Oral and Visual Communication
- Express and respond to a range of ideas and opinions concisely,
clearly, and appropriately
- Contribute and work constructively in groups
- Use tone of voice and body language to clarify meaning during
conversations and presentations
- Contribute collaboratively in group situations by asking questions
and building on the ideas of others
- Work with members of their group to establish clear purposes
and procedures for solving problems and completing projects
The Arts: Drama and Dance
- Critique, orally and in writing, their own and others’ work
in drama and dance, using criteria developed independently and
in a group
- Critique solutions to problems presented in drama and dance,
make decisions in large and small groups, and defend their artistic
choices
- Demonstrate understanding of the appropriate use of the voice,
gestures, and the level of language in different dramatic situations
- Produce pieces that deal appropriately with youth problems
- Produce pieces of writing in which they reflect on their experiences
in drama and dance, and in which they show their ability to analyse
and find solutions to problems in real life
Health and Physical Education: Healthy Living
- Identify local support groups and community organizations (e.g.,
public health offices) that provide information or services related
to health and well-being
- Analyse situations that are potentially dangerous to personal
safety (e.g., gang violence) and determine how to seek assistance
- Analyse situations (e.g., hitchhiking, gang violence, violence
in relationships) that are potentially dangerous to personal safety
- Identify support services (e.g., the school guidance department,
shelters, Kid’s Help Phone) that assist victims of violence,
and explain how to access them
Health and Physical Education: Active Participation
- Demonstrate respectful behaviour towards the feelings and ideas
of others
- Follow the rules of fair play and sports etiquette in games
and activities (e.g., maintaining self-control whether winning
or losing)
Catholic Education Religion and Family Life
Religion:
-
responsible choices, self respect, respect for others, service in the community
Family Life:
- developing our gifts
- conflict resolution
- building a loving, just community and exploring social issues
Toolkit Evaluation:
(where noted: Consistently (C) Often (O))
Exploring Well-Being Through Relationships
Knowledge
- How healthy relationships support a healthy sense of
well-being (O)
- Differentiate between healthy/equal relationships and
relationships that are negative/unequal (p.139) (O)
- Increase awareness of how actions and choices impact
the well being of others (O)
- Increase awareness of how actions/choices of others impact
personal well-being (O)
(Allows and encourages students to analyze
healthy vs. unhealthy relationships in their lives. Students are
encouraged to analyze how these relationships make them feel.)
Skills
- Explore relationships from personal perspectives and
experiences (O)
- Define values of healthy, supportive and caring relationships (C)
- Express personal feelings, thoughts, and experiences (O)
Exploring Social Relations of Violence, Oppression and Equality
Knowledge
- Knowledge about social structures of inequality, marginalization/exclusion,
negative stereotypes, discrimination and violence (O)
- Develop a gender analysis of social relations (O)
- Develop understanding of multiple forms and contexts
of violence (O)
- Recognize and make connections of varied forms of violence
in different contexts (i.e., home, school, community, media etc.) (C)
- A wide array of violence; in the home, family violence,
dating violence, bullying. Emotional abuse: examines the feelings
of both male and female involved.
Skills
- Explore multiple and different forms of violence/vulnerability
and experiences of exclusion in their lives (C)
- Explore gendered aspects of their social identities,
relationships and experiences (O)
- Explore personal experiences of vulnerability and privilege
by understanding social inequality/oppressions. (O)
- Opportunity to personalize knowledge of social relations
of oppression and empowerment (C)
Exploring Identity, Gender, and Diversity
Knowledge
- Knowledge to examine social identities relationships
and experiences within the context of multiple social relationships
and structure of inequality (vulnerability vs. privilege) (O)
- Knowledge about how values and biases are (can be) used
to exclude and cause harm to individuals and groups of individuals (O)
Children affected by violence vs. women affected by violence.
Skills
- Opportunity for students to identify, explore, and name
their own identities, experiences, and values (C)
- Opportunity for students to develop an understanding
and respect for the identities, experiences, and values of their
classmates/peers (O)
- socioeconomic status, culture, religion, sexual orientation
with respect and interest (O)
- Opportunity for students to express, learn from, and
build multiple perspectives on social experiences and diversity (O)
- Identify personal triggers to anger. Opportunity to discuss
bullying and how to prevent it.
Developing Connections, Creative Thinking and Participation
Knowledge
- Validation of students’ perspective and knowledge
in understanding violence and healthy relationships (O)
- Strategies for personal and/or social change are offered
to students for the promotion of healthy and equal relationships. (O)
- Engagement in learning conflict resolution and anti-violence
strategies (C)
- Gain in knowledge about choices and actions that promote
mutual empowerment and respect (O)
What matters in a relationship? ‘Healthy relationship’ quiz in conflict resolution chapter.
Skills
- Opportunities to develop and practice their capacity for healthy
interactions and connections within the context of the classroom/school (O) (role play and discussion)
- Opportunities to work collaboratively with peers to discuss and
develop strategies for healthy and equal relationships (O)
- Experience and practice how to resolve conflict positively (O)
- Opportunity for the development of supportive connections between
students and teachers/adults (O)
(The source presents some methods for conflict resolution.)
Pedagogical Evaluation:
Structure and Format:
- Research-based introduction
- Evaluation of the resource (e.g., formal research on the effectiveness
of the program
- Strategies to integrate lessons/activities into the educational
curriculum
- Information guide or scope and sequence of lessons (i.e. how
to strategies)
- Sequential guide or lessons that are user friendly
- Availability of support to implement the program/resource
Teaching/Learning Strategies:
Direct Instruction: whole class and small group
- Explicit Teaching
- Demonstration
- Explicit teaching and use of thinking skills and strategies
- Explicit teaching and using self-assessment and reflection
Interactive Learning
- Small-group cooperative learning
- Small group discussion/debriefing
- Presentations (role play)
- brainstorming
Indirect Instruction
- Guided teacher-directed inquiry
- Guided student-directed inquiry
- Reflective discussions
Experiential Learning
- Simulation, role play
- Case studies/scenarios
Teaching and Learning Activities/Lessons Include:
- Choice, where possible, in student tasks and assignments
- Multiple opportunities for practice and feedback.
- Use of graphic organizers (e.g. Venn diagrams, mind maps,
tables) (limited)
- Opportunities to use computer/information literacy skills
- Opportunities for students to use their learning styles
to learn and demonstrate learning
- Integration of Multiple Intelligences theory to learn
and demonstrate their learning.
- Oral and written reflection/journal writing (mainly writing)
Assessment Methods:
Pencil and Paper:
Demonstration/Performance:
- Class
- Skills demonstrations
- Role playing
- Simulations
Personal Communication:
- Journals
- Students assess their own learning and set specific goals
Other:
- Staff training
- School-wide connections
Strengths Summary:
This resource differentiates between healthy relationships and unhealthy relationships, encourages students to analyze healthy versus unhealthy relationships in their own lives, and to analyze how these relationships make them feel. The resource helps increase student awareness of how their actions/choices impact the well-being of others. It encourages students to look at relationships from a personal perspective.
The resource promotes an understanding of multiple forms and contexts of violence. For example, violence in the home, family violence, dating violence, emotional abuse, and more.
The source examines violence using a gender analysis and an analysis of social relations.
It examines social identities/relationships and experiences (ex. the ways in which children vs. women experience violence). It allows for the identification of personal triggers to anger and encourages students to explore personal identities, experiences, and values.
This source provides the opportunity for students to gain respect for peers by discussing in groups, ways in which to stop bullying. It also offers strategies for personal/social change and promotion of healthy and equal relationships. There is a ‘healthy relationships’ quiz and a conflict resolution chapter. The resource provides opportunities for students to develop and practice their own capacity for healthy relationships through role playing and debriefing.
This resource differentiates between healthy relationships and unhealthy relationships, encourages students to analyze healthy versus unhealthy relationships in their own lives, and to analyze how these relationships make them feel. The resource helps increase student awareness of how their actions/choices impact the well-being of others. It encourages students to look at relationships from a personal perspective.
The resource promotes an understanding of multiple forms and contexts of violence. For example, violence in the home, family violence, dating violence, emotional abuse, and more.
The source examines violence using a gender analysis and an analysis of social relations.
It examines social identities/relationships and experiences (ex. the ways in which children vs. women experience violence). It allows for the identification of personal triggers to anger and encourages students to explore personal identities, experiences, and values.
This source provides the opportunity for students to gain respect for peers by discussing in groups, ways in which to stop bullying. It also offers strategies for personal/social change and promotion of healthy and equal relationships. There is a ‘healthy relationships’ quiz and a conflict resolution chapter. The resource provides opportunities for students to develop and practice their own capacity for healthy relationships through role playing and debriefing.